Should you repair a torn ACL? That’s a surprisingly tricky question

Perth Glory’s Dino Djulbic tore the anterior cruciate ligament in his right knee in the 60th minute of his team’s grand final loss to Sydney FC in May 2019.

For nearly all 36-year-old athletes, that would be the end of their career.

But just under five months later – without surgery – Djulbic lined up for his second match since recovering; for Perth Glory in Saturday’s match against Western United. He played his first last week, just 147 days since the injury. He’s being heralded as a ‘miracle man’.

“The surgeon recommended surgery,” Djulbic, 36, told The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age. “I said ‘look mate, that’s not an option. I can’t take 12 months off. I am out of contract, my career would be done. What are the odds of recovery without surgery?’

“He said ‘about 20 to 30 per cent’.

“Five per cent I would have thought twice, but 20 to 30 per cent – I loved those odds.”

Knee reconstruction

Front view of knee with patella (knee cap) not shown

The next day he was in the gym at 5:30am, working to strengthen his leg muscles. He went through intensive physiotherapy from the club’s medical team. He would do this every day for the next 10 weeks.

After two and half months, Djulbic was running straight lines. Soon after that he was changing direction. In three months he was back into full training with his teammates.

“I know the injury is there but it’s what you put in your head,” he says. “If you’re a little bit stronger minded you don’t accept you’re defeated, that’s a big thing.”

Djulbic’s recovery is an example of the mysteries of the most controversial ligament in the human body: the ACL.

The ligament runs diagonally through the knee and keeps it stable. Tear it, and most people – athletes included – will immediately seek surgery.

That turns out to be far more controversial than you would think.

Knee surgeons say surgery stops further damage to the knee in young active people and keeps it stable.

Other scientists say there is no strong evidence ACL surgery works any better than not doing surgery. Many people do fine without an ACL and don’t need surgery at all, they say.

“It’s very brave to tackle this topic,” says Professor Evangelos Pappas, a top ACL researcher and head of the University of Sydney’s physiotherapy school. “It’s very controversial.”

“The outcomes after ACL surgery has rightfully been questioned, because when we follow the outcomes of these athletes after surgery are not very good.”

Studies show almost a quarter of athletes – and a third of AFL footballers – who receive ACL reconstruction surgery will reinjure their ACL. Less than half of patients will return to competitive sport.

And there are many stories of people seemingly able to cope without an ACL, some even returning to top-level sport. Penrith Panthers halfback Peter Wallace played two seasons without an ACL; NBA basketballer DeJuan Blair played over 450 games without ACLs in either knee.

Professor Pappas believes too many people opt for surgery when there is another way: a physical rehab program that trains leg muscles to increase stability.

Some people will find they still need the surgery, but in other cases a good recovery can be made without it.

In 2013 Swedish researchers tested rehab against ACL surgery in a trial published in The BMJ. After five years there were no differences between the two groups in pain, sports function, and how their knee injuries affected their daily lives.

“Currently,” says Professor Pappas, “there is no evidence that surgery is superior to rehab.”

Orthopaedic surgeon Professor Christopher Vertullo is president of the Australian Knee Society.

He argues the Swedish study has major flaws – about half of those who got rehab later asked for surgery, for example – and points to other research suggesting people who don’t get surgery are at a higher risk of damaging their knee further, requiring a total knee replacement in the future.

“The Swedes don’t play AFL or netball. And if you don’t reconstruct active young athletes and they come back with a bucket-handle tear of the [knee cartilage] due to instability, then you’ve got a big problem,” he says.

“There are risks with not having an operation that athletes should be aware of, particularly tearing the knee cartilage. The large long-term studies – and this is debatable – would suggest young and active people should have a reconstruction.”

Both Professor Pappas and Professor Vertullo agree that some people, like Djulbic, do fine without an ACL.

The question is who these people are. Science still cannot tell who should have the operation and who can give it a miss.

People who want to return to basketball and soccer should consider surgery, Professor Pappas recommends.

Information from: https://amp-smh-com-au.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/amp.smh.com.au/national/should-you-repair-a-torn-acl-that-s-a-surprisingly-tricky-question-20191019-p53282.html

Share this post

Hi, would you like to chat with one of our physios?

Please provide your contact details and one of our experienced physiotherapists will give you a free, no obligation call to assist you with your query. 

m mooney
m mooney
04:59 09 Jul 24
Julie Dimevski
Julie Dimevski
08:04 26 Jun 24
Kieran and the team have provided great customer service during my daughters recovery. They show care, and are supportive. He has been open and transparent, and positive. Thanks Kieran and team.
Tim merchant
Tim merchant
06:42 23 Apr 24
Really inviting staff, always ready to help. They know what they are talking about and facilites are wonderful.
Ashley Williams
Ashley Williams
10:55 03 Apr 24
best in the business the team here are the very best at their jobs
G G
G G
16:52 05 Mar 24
I came to Jubilee Sports Physio for help on how to exersise and get fit without injuring myself constantly.During my initial consultation Michael said, I was standing wrong, sitting wrong and exersises I did were not suitable for my body.After four sessions, 15 minutes of daily exercises in between and I can go on hikes, lift weights and feel many years younger.I now have the life I want and very grateful to Jubilee Sports Physio, for their professionalism from booking, greeting and being able to do all I want physically.I highly recommend Jubilee Sports
Lara Mangelli
Lara Mangelli
08:56 18 Dec 23
I would like to express my sincere appreciation for the exceptional care provided by Michael and James for attending to my son, both before and after his shoulder reconstruction. Michael and James' combination of kindness and professionalism played an important role in helping my son navigate through what was his first significant life challenge.They both demonstrated an unwavering commitment to my son's well-being, providing not only expert physiotherapy but also a level of compassionate support that went above and beyond.Thank you Jubilee team for your outstanding commitment to patient care. It's reassuring to know that professionals like Michael and James are dedicated to not just addressing physical challenges but also fostering a supportive and empathetic environment for individuals facing health setbacks. The receptions ladies were kind and helpful too.
Judith Gifford
Judith Gifford
06:00 18 Dec 23
Over a period of 4 years my husband and I have had the expertise and professionalism of Michael Gabriel and staff at Jubilee Sports Physiotherapy Each of our ageing conditions required commitment to exercises to improve. When the conditions were clearly explained we gained confidence and understanding of realistic outcomes. We feel very fortunate for all of our treatments..and highly recommend Michael and staff.
Georgia Manos
Georgia Manos
12:08 13 Dec 23
The whole Jubilee team is fantastic. They are professional, knowledgeable and have always gotten me back playing football as quick as possible!
Jordan Figon
Jordan Figon
06:36 13 Dec 23
The team at Jubilee have been looking after me for over 15 years. Specially Michael with the help of Kieran. They have rehabbed me through 4 major surgeries as well as long standing injuries. It is because of these guys, I am able to still be involved in the game I love, stretching my career out as long as possible. In addition, my whole family is part of the Jubilee family
David Washington
David Washington
05:02 13 Dec 23
I have relied on Michael Gabriel for my physiotherapy needs for a number of years now. His professional work has allowed me to continue to chase the love I have for outdoors recreation.
Luke Payne
Luke Payne
22:05 12 Dec 23
Michael and his team are the best. So professional and knowledgeable and have kept me moving for years.
Diane sutton
Diane sutton
21:58 12 Dec 23
I have been a patient of Jubilee Sports Physio for many years, being treated for various injuries & chronic conditions. Michael’s diagnostic skills are excellent. I can highly recommend this practice for their care, proficiency & friendliness.
Nicole Simpson
Nicole Simpson
10:53 12 Dec 23
Micheal has helped over the years to heal and help with my injuries.. The entire team gives a five star help. I can’t praise them enough…Thank you so much
Judy Andrews
Judy Andrews
10:26 12 Dec 23
Michael has treated me on a number of occasions. He is very professional and very easy to talk to. He obviously knows his stuff and never fails to set you on the right path with his treatments
BERGE GABO
BERGE GABO
09:28 12 Dec 23
"I have been going to Jubilee Physiotherapy for many years.Very professional from the receptionists to the principal Physioswith lots of experience and straight to the point thatsave time and money"
Corinne Favaloro
Corinne Favaloro
04:09 02 Nov 23
I have been attending Jubilee physio, on and off, for many years.In fact three generations of my family are presently receiving treatment there. I have had several of the physiotherapist at Jubilee work on different problems and have found them all to be professional, knowledgeable and very caring in their treatment.
Nicole Di noia
Nicole Di noia
22:19 01 Nov 23
Thorough, professional and passionate team of physiotherapists.
Steve Chidgey
Steve Chidgey
02:04 04 Jul 23
The the treatment I received for injury was first class. Caring, knowledgeable and highly professional. The electronic home exercising provided to me showed me the required exercises so I was not let to a piece of papers directing me. Loved the app. This physio is the best I have used. Highly recommended.
Margaret Peace
Margaret Peace
01:29 01 Jul 23
I have attended Jubilee Physiotherapy for many years and have always had a positive experience. The staff are professional and knowledgeable. I always feel comfortable and safe in their care.My therapist, Samuel Leslie, knew exactly how to treat my new neck issue. As a result, I have made a very good recovery.
Angelina Mastoris
Angelina Mastoris
23:09 01 Mar 23
The guys at Jubilee are amazing! Been going for a couple years and each time I’ve had a great experience. Massive shout out and thanks to our team Physio Sam for helping me with my rehab and recovery. He’s helped improve my overall game and has made me stronger than before. He’s a legend. Would highly recommend, overall fantastic experience!
See All Reviews
js_loader

Hi, would you like to chat with one of our physios?

Please provide your contact details and one of our experienced physiotherapists will give you a free, no obligation call to assist you with your query.